|
|
Oh,
What a Blow That Phantom Gave Me! by Edmund Carpenter
|
|
|
PORTRAITS
I
think precisely the type of studio Irving Penn employed, where subjects
are photographed in limbo, using a good camera & sealing prints in
clear plastic, should be set up all through New Guinea. Its primary virtue
would be as counterforce to radio. It
is one of the ironies of change in New Guinea that the introduction of
the camera, though traumatic & disruptive of tribal life, must now
be encouraged to offset the even greater trauma & disruption caused
by radio. Human sensory balance must now be sought in terms of media balance.
A
photograph moves us toward the isolated moment. It arrests time. It exists
in pure space. It emphasizes individuality, private identity, and confers
an element of permanence on that image. In many ways, it's the exact opposite
of radio. Such
studios could easily become self-supporting, providing indigenous employment.
Interest is already there. We
used up a great quantity of film during a six-week stay in Mintima, a
Chimbu village in the Central Highlands. It became widely known we would
take anyone's photograph, free, and there was always a crowd waiting.
Many walked considerable distances. I recall a policeman who walked fifteen
miles only to encounter rain, so he returned the next day, walking a total
of sixty miles for one picture. A
photographic portrait, when new & privately possessed, promotes identity,
individualism: it offers opportunities for self-recognition, self-study.
It provides the extra sensation of objectivizing the self. It makes that
self more real, more dramatic. For the subject, it's no longer enough
to be: now he knows he is. He is conscious of himself. Until
man becomes conscious of his personal appearance & his private identity,
there is little self-expression. Sartre,
in The Words, speaks of his mother: "Anne Marie, the younger
daughter, spent her childhood on a chair. She was taught to be bored,
to sit up straight, to sew. She was gifted: the family thought it distinguished
to leave her gifts underdeveloped; she was radiant: they hid the fact
from her ... beauty was beyond their means ... fifty years later, when
turning the pages of a family album, Anne Marie realized that she had
been beautiful." In
New Guinea, subjects who understood what a camera was & chose to pose
before it generally faced the camera directly. But a few of the elders
offered their profiles. I recall one elderly man, dressed as a warrior,
who turned to one side & began to shout toward the horizon. I had
the feeling this posture derived from some ancient battlefield. One
day at a marriage ceremony, we offered to photograph the bridal couple.
The groom immediately posed with a male friend. We re-posed him with his
pregnant bride & year-old child. Some weeks later we visited their
home & saw this photograph carefully pinned up. Actually,
the incident was infinitely more complicated than this brief account indicates.
It was instantly obvious from the behavior of everyone present that the
picture he had requested would have been routine, whereas the picture
we took was anything but routine. It was as if we had photographed, in
our society, the groom kissing the best man. All the power & prestige
of the camera had been used in direct conflict with one of the deepest
cultural values of this Highland New Guinea society. If
I were a missionary, dedicated to promoting & preserving the Christian
family, I would buy the biggest camera I could find, photograph all wedding
couples & supply each with a large print, elaborately framed. In
our own culture, the sanctity & reality of marriage was declared as
much in wedding photographs as it was in written documents. I think the
power of such pictures would be even greater in New Guinea. Since
I'm not a missionary, not dedicated to promoting alien values at the expense
of indigenous ones, I offer this as an illustration & speculation,
not as a recommendation. |
|
Pages
143-145
Oh, What a Blow That Phantom Gave Me! by Edmund Carpenter Holt, Rinehart and Winston - New York, Chicago, San Francisco Copyright 1972, 1973 by Edmund Carpenter translated to hypermedia and edited by Michael Wesch 2002 |